Legalising Assisted Dying in England and Wales
On November 11, 2024, a landmark bill, the Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill, was introduced to Parliament. It aims to legalise physician-assisted dying for terminally ill adults in England and Wales.
This proposed legislation has sparked significant interest, particularly among healthcare professionals, social workers, and those involved in palliative care. The bill outlines a clear process and strict safeguards to ensure that assisted dying is a voluntary, informed choice for terminally ill individuals.
Background: The Legal Context of Assisted Dying
In England and Wales, assisting someone to die has long been prohibited under the Suicide Act 1961, which criminalises any act that encourages or assists a person in committing suicide, with offenders facing up to 14 years in prison. Despite this, assisted dying has been a contentious issue in the UK for years.
The European Court of Human Rights allows countries a wide margin of appreciation regarding the legality of assisted dying, and several nations, such as Switzerland, have already legalised assisted suicide.
The last time the UK Parliament voted on this issue was in 2015. Now, the *Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill* aims to provide a legal framework for assisted dying while maintaining safeguards against abuse or coercion.
Who Is Eligible for Assisted Dying?
The bill sets out strict criteria to ensure that only those who meet specific conditions can seek assistance to end their lives. To be eligible, a person must:
– Be 18 years or older.
– Be ordinarily resident in England or Wales for at least 12 months.
– Be registered with a GP in England or Wales.
– Have the mental capacity to make an informed decision under the Mental Capacity Act 2005.
– Be diagnosed with a terminal illness that is expected to lead to death within six months.
Notably, the bill excludes individuals whose condition is solely a mental disorder or disability.
The Assisted Dying Process: A Three-Stage Approach
The bill introduces a rigorous, multi-step process to safeguard the interests of terminally ill patients. This involves two separate declarations and court oversight, ensuring the decision to end life is voluntary and informed.
Stage 1: First Declaration and Medical Assessment
A terminally ill person must first sign a “first declaration,” stating that they meet the eligibility criteria and wish to end their life. This declaration must be witnessed by a “co-ordinating doctor” and another independent witness.
The coordinating doctor will then assess the patient’s capacity and ensure there is no coercion or pressure. A second independent doctor must also evaluate the patient, with a minimum seven-day reflection period between assessments.
Stage 2: Court Approval
After the two medical assessments, the patient can apply to the High Court for approval to proceed with assisted dying. The court’s role is to confirm that all legal requirements have been met. The patient can proceed if approved, but they have the right to appeal if their request is denied.
Stage 3: Second Declaration
Following court approval, the patient must make a second declaration confirming their decision. There is a mandatory 14-day reflection period before the second declaration can be made, although this can be shortened to 48 hours if the patient is expected to die within a month. The second declaration must again be signed and witnessed.
The Role of the Co-ordinating Doctor
The bill stipulates that assisted dying can only occur under the supervision of a registered medical professional, referred to as the “co-ordinating doctor.” The doctor is responsible for providing the approved substance for self-administration. However, the patient must perform the final act—ingesting or administering the substance. The doctor may also authorise another medical practitioner to perform these functions if necessary.
Protections and Safeguards for Healthcare Professionals
While the bill allows physicians to assist in dying, it also respects the rights of healthcare professionals who object to the practice. Doctors are not obligated to participate, and employees cannot face discrimination for choosing not to engage in assisted dying procedures.
Furthermore, the bill provides legal protection to doctors who assist patients by the law. The *Suicide Act 1961* will be amended to ensure that helping with this bill does not constitute an offence, as long as the doctor acted in good faith and took reasonable precautions.
Preventing Abuse: Criminal Offenses and Penalties
The bill creates several new criminal offences to prevent misuse or abuse of the assisted dying process. It will be illegal to:
– Use coercion or pressure to induce someone to declare their wish to die.
– Make or use false declarations.
– Provide false or misleading medical information to secure approval for assisted dying.
Offenders could face up to 14 years in prison for these violations, ensuring the process remains transparent and free from external manipulation.
Looking Ahead: The Bill’s Next Steps
The bill is scheduled for debate in Parliament on November 29, 2024. If passed, further debates and votes will follow before it can become law. Assisted dying legislation remains a divisive issue, and MPs will have a free vote on the matter, reflecting the complexity and ethical considerations surrounding end-of-life care.
The proposed law would apply only to England and Wales. Similar discussions are happening elsewhere in the UK, including Scotland, Jersey, and the Isle of Man, where steps are being taken to introduce assisted dying legislation.
Conclusion
The Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill represents a significant shift in end-of-life care, providing terminally ill patients in England and Wales the right to choose an assisted death under strict conditions.
With robust safeguards in place, the bill aims to balance compassion for those suffering from terminal illnesses with the need to prevent abuse.
Looking for support in adult social care? Our team boasts a wealth of experience and years in the field, promising ethical and knowledgeable assessment services.
